{"claims":[{"about":"c_aiki","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aiki_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_connection","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_aiki","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aiki_in_aikido","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_aikido"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_aiki","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aiki_in_daito","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_daito"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_aiki","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aiki_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Aiki"},{"about":"c_aiki","author":"robliberti","evidence":[{"ref":"e_amdur"}],"id":"k_aiki_peng_biomech","kind":"relation","rationale":"Both describe a connected frame that redirects incoming force to the ground without local resistance.","scope":{"d_lens":"p_biomech"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_peng","type":"analogous-to"}},{"about":"c_aiki","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aiki_peng_denied_chen","kind":"relation","rationale":"Peng is a constant quality of every posture, trained through form and silk reeling; equating it with a contact skill from another art hides how differently the two are built.","scope":{"d_art":"p_chen"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"state":"denied","to":"c_peng","type":"analogous-to"}},{"about":"c_aiki","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aiki_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_aikiage","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aikiage_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_methods","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_aikiage","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aikiage_dev_aiki","kind":"relation","scope":{"d_art":"p_daito"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_aiki","type":"develops"}},{"about":"c_aikiage","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aikiage_dev_kokyu","kind":"relation","scope":{"d_art":"p_aikido"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_kokyu","type":"develops"}},{"about":"c_aikiage","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aikiage_in_aikido","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_aikido"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_aikiage","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aikiage_in_daito","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_daito"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_aikiage","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aikiage_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Seated rising exercise"},{"about":"c_aikiage","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aikiage_label_aikido","kind":"label","lang":"ja","scope":{"d_art":"p_aikido"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Kokyū-hō (呼吸法)"},{"about":"c_aikiage","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aikiage_label_daito","kind":"label","lang":"ja","scope":{"d_art":"p_daito"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Aiki-age (合気上げ)"},{"about":"c_aikiage","author":"robliberti","id":"k_aikiage_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_breath","author":"robliberti","id":"k_breath_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_internal","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_breath","author":"robliberti","id":"k_breath_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Breath"},{"about":"c_breath","author":"robliberti","id":"k_breath_related_center","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_center","type":"related"}},{"about":"c_center","author":"robliberti","id":"k_center_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_internal","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_center","author":"robliberti","id":"k_center_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Lower abdominal centre"},{"about":"c_center","author":"robliberti","id":"k_center_label_aikido","kind":"label","lang":"ja-Latn-hepburn","scope":{"d_art":"p_aikido"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Tanden / hara"},{"about":"c_center","author":"robliberti","id":"k_center_label_biomech","kind":"label","scope":{"d_lens":"p_biomech"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Centre-of-mass region"},{"about":"c_center","author":"robliberti","id":"k_center_label_daito","kind":"label","lang":"ja","scope":{"d_art":"p_daito"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Tanden (丹田)"},{"about":"c_center","author":"robliberti","id":"k_center_label_taichi","kind":"label","lang":"zh-Hant","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Dantian (丹田)"},{"about":"c_chansi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_chansi_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_power","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_chansi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_chansi_in_chen","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_chen"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_chansi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_chansi_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Chan si jin (silk reeling)"},{"about":"c_chansi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_chansi_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_chansigong","author":"robliberti","id":"k_chansigong_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_methods","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_chansigong","author":"robliberti","id":"k_chansigong_dev_chansi","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_chansi","type":"develops"}},{"about":"c_chansigong","author":"robliberti","id":"k_chansigong_in_chen","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_chen"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_chansigong","author":"robliberti","id":"k_chansigong_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Silk-reeling exercises (chan si gong)"},{"about":"c_chansigong","author":"robliberti","id":"k_chansigong_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_connection","author":"robliberti","id":"k_connection_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_internal","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_connection","author":"robliberti","id":"k_connection_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Connection & sensitivity"},{"about":"c_fajin","author":"robliberti","id":"k_fajin_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_power","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_fajin","author":"robliberti","id":"k_fajin_in_chen_found","kind":"presence","rationale":"Chen-style first routines contain overt issuing movements, so beginners meet it from the start.","scope":{"d_art":"p_chen","d_level":"p_found"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_fajin","author":"robliberti","id":"k_fajin_in_taichi_inter","kind":"presence","rationale":"Issuing is normally trained after relaxation and rooting are reliable.","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi","d_level":"p_inter"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_fajin","author":"robliberti","id":"k_fajin_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Fa jin (issuing)"},{"about":"c_fajin","author":"robliberti","id":"k_fajin_part_seq","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_tinghuanafa","type":"part-of"}},{"about":"c_fajin","author":"robliberti","id":"k_fajin_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_hua","author":"robliberti","id":"k_hua_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_connection","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_hua","author":"robliberti","id":"k_hua_in_taichi","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_hua","author":"robliberti","id":"k_hua_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Hua jin (neutralising)"},{"about":"c_hua","author":"robliberti","id":"k_hua_part_seq","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_tinghuanafa","type":"part-of"}},{"about":"c_hua","author":"robliberti","id":"k_hua_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_intent","author":"robliberti","id":"k_intent_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_internal","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_intent","author":"robliberti","id":"k_intent_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Intent"},{"about":"c_internal","author":"robliberti","id":"k_internal_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Internal skill"},{"about":"c_kokyu","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kokyu_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_breath","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_kokyu","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kokyu_in_aikido","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_aikido"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_kokyu","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kokyu_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Kokyū-ryoku (breath power)"},{"about":"c_kokyu","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kokyu_not_breath_biomech","kind":"relation","rationale":"Described mechanically, the skill is not a breathing method.","scope":{"d_lens":"p_biomech"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"state":"denied","to":"c_breath","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_kokyu","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kokyu_power_biomech","kind":"relation","scope":{"d_lens":"p_biomech"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_power","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_kokyu","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kokyu_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_kuzushi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kuzushi_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_connection","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_kuzushi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kuzushi_in_aikido","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_aikido"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_kuzushi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kuzushi_in_daito","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_daito"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_kuzushi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kuzushi_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Kuzushi (balance breaking)"},{"about":"c_kuzushi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kuzushi_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_kuzushi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_kuzushi_tested_shiai","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_shiai","type":"tested-by"}},{"about":"c_li","author":"robliberti","id":"k_li_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_internal","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_li","author":"robliberti","id":"k_li_contrasts_power","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_power","type":"contrasts-with"}},{"about":"c_li","author":"robliberti","id":"k_li_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Local muscular force"},{"about":"c_methods","author":"robliberti","id":"k_methods_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Training methods"},{"about":"c_musubi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_musubi_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_connection","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_musubi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_musubi_in_aikido","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_aikido"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_musubi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_musubi_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Musubi (tying together)"},{"about":"c_musubi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_musubi_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_musubi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_musubi_ting","kind":"relation","rationale":"Both are the skill of joining with the partner through contact before acting.","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_ting","type":"analogous-to"}},{"about":"c_peng","author":"robliberti","id":"k_peng_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_structure","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_peng","author":"robliberti","id":"k_peng_in_taichi","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_peng","author":"robliberti","id":"k_peng_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Peng jin"},{"about":"c_peng","author":"robliberti","id":"k_peng_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_power","author":"robliberti","id":"k_power_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_internal","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_power","author":"robliberti","id":"k_power_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Whole-body power"},{"about":"c_pushhands","author":"robliberti","id":"k_pushhands_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_methods","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_pushhands","author":"robliberti","id":"k_pushhands_dev_ting","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_ting","type":"develops"}},{"about":"c_pushhands","author":"robliberti","id":"k_pushhands_in_taichi","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_pushhands","author":"robliberti","id":"k_pushhands_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Push hands (tui shou)"},{"about":"c_pushhands","author":"robliberti","id":"k_pushhands_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_qi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_qi_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_internal","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_qi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_qi_in_biomech_taichi","kind":"presence","rationale":"Tai Chi instruction cannot be followed without the term, so the lens keeps it and explains its use.","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi","d_lens":"p_biomech"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_qi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_qi_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Qi / ki"},{"about":"c_qi","author":"robliberti","id":"k_qi_not_biomech","kind":"presence","rationale":"Qi is not a construct in mechanics; the lens describes the same training effects in other terms.","scope":{"d_lens":"p_biomech"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_relax","author":"robliberti","id":"k_relax_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_internal","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_relax","author":"robliberti","id":"k_relax_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Relaxation"},{"about":"c_relax","author":"robliberti","id":"k_relax_label_taichi","kind":"label","lang":"zh-Hant","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Song (鬆)"},{"about":"c_relax","author":"robliberti","id":"k_relax_pre_peng","kind":"relation","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_peng","type":"prerequisite-of"}},{"about":"c_rooting","author":"robliberti","id":"k_rooting_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_structure","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_rooting","author":"robliberti","id":"k_rooting_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Rooting"},{"about":"c_rooting","author":"robliberti","id":"k_rooting_pre_fajin","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_fajin","type":"prerequisite-of"}},{"about":"c_shiai","author":"robliberti","id":"k_shiai_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_methods","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_shiai","author":"robliberti","id":"k_shiai_in_shodokan","kind":"presence","rationale":"Tomiki Kenji introduced randori competition; Shōdōkan Aikido holds matches.","scope":{"d_art":"p_shodokan"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_shiai","author":"robliberti","id":"k_shiai_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Competitive matches"},{"about":"c_shiai","author":"robliberti","id":"k_shiai_not_aikido","kind":"presence","rationale":"Most Aikido organisations follow the founder's rejection of competition.","scope":{"d_art":"p_aikido"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_shiai","author":"robliberti","id":"k_shiai_not_daito","kind":"presence","rationale":"Daitō-ryū is transmitted through paired kata; it has no competitive format.","scope":{"d_art":"p_daito"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_structure","author":"robliberti","id":"k_structure_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_internal","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_structure","author":"robliberti","id":"k_structure_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Body structure"},{"about":"c_ting","author":"robliberti","id":"k_ting_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_connection","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_ting","author":"robliberti","id":"k_ting_in_taichi","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_ting","author":"robliberti","id":"k_ting_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Ting jin (listening)"},{"about":"c_ting","author":"robliberti","id":"k_ting_part_seq","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_tinghuanafa","type":"part-of"}},{"about":"c_ting","author":"robliberti","id":"k_ting_pre_hua","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_hua","type":"prerequisite-of"}},{"about":"c_ting","author":"robliberti","id":"k_ting_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_ting","author":"robliberti","id":"k_ting_tested_pushhands","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_pushhands","type":"tested-by"}},{"about":"c_tinghuanafa","author":"robliberti","id":"k_tinghuanafa_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_internal","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_tinghuanafa","author":"robliberti","id":"k_tinghuanafa_in_taichi","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_tinghuanafa","author":"robliberti","id":"k_tinghuanafa_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Listen, neutralise, seize, issue"},{"about":"c_tinghuanafa","author":"robliberti","id":"k_tinghuanafa_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"},{"about":"c_zhanzhuang","author":"robliberti","id":"k_zhanzhuang_broader","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_methods","type":"broader"}},{"about":"c_zhanzhuang","author":"robliberti","id":"k_zhanzhuang_dev_relax","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_relax","type":"develops"}},{"about":"c_zhanzhuang","author":"robliberti","id":"k_zhanzhuang_dev_rooting","kind":"relation","updated":"2026-10-02","value":{"to":"c_rooting","type":"develops"}},{"about":"c_zhanzhuang","author":"robliberti","id":"k_zhanzhuang_in_taichi","kind":"presence","scope":{"d_art":"p_taichi"},"updated":"2026-10-02","value":"present"},{"about":"c_zhanzhuang","author":"robliberti","id":"k_zhanzhuang_label","kind":"label","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"Standing post (zhan zhuang)"},{"about":"c_zhanzhuang","author":"robliberti","id":"k_zhanzhuang_restricted","kind":"presence","updated":"2026-10-02","value":"absent"}]}